"; } ?>
Namadwaar
Nama Dwaar
 
Nama Dwaar Answers

Back to questions...

 Question
 

In Ramayana, why did Sri Rama kill Vali, hiding behind a tree?

 Sri Sri Swamiji's Answer

 

Who was Ravana? Ravana was the one who confiscated Sita Devi, the lovable wife of Sri Rama. Even when Sri Rama faced Ravana, He turned him back saying ‘Indru POi NALai Vaa’ (Go back and return tomorrow’). Why did he do so? An ocean of infinite compassion that He was, Sri Rama waited to see if Ravana surrendered to Him, or at least befriended Him, so that He could let go of Ravana. How can such an ocean of mercy kill Vali from the hiding?

Sri Rama neither avowed to Himself (‘sankalpa’) nor promised anyone that He would kill Ravana. However, in the case of Vali, He had promised Sugriva that He would slay Vali. Thus, when the result was pre-decided, had Sri Rama waged a battle with Vali, Vali would have brought a huge ‘vanara sena’ (army of monkeys), and they would be killed in the battle for no fault or reason. Out of sheer compassion for those monkeys, Sri Rama decided that He would kill Vali from the hiding, very well aware that He would be blamed for doing so, for centuries and centuries to go.

There is another connotation to it too:

Sri Rama was an avatar of Maha Vishnu, the supreme Lord. Hanuman was the Guru of Sugriva. It is the Guru who shows the Lord to the disciple and so did Hanuman bring Sri Rama unto Sugriva. Not only that; through God, the Guru fulfils the disciple’s wish.

Here Valmiki underlines a very important fact – “The Lord will do anything to keep up the word of the Guru, unmindful of the consequences”. That was the reason Sri Rama killed Vali from behind the tree.

Another interesting fact is being subtly painted by Valmiki here: Sugriva does not show as much love, obedience, devotion and respect to Sri Rama as Hanuman did. This shows that, these factors are more important for the Guru than for the disciple himself, and that, the Lord will keep up Guru’s words, even if the devotee does not confide in Him completely.

 

Your comments and feedback are valuable. Please send them by clicking here.

 

 

 Other Responses

P.N. NATARAJ

  1. According to Sanadhana Dharma for abducting another person's wife, death sentence is the judgement (Vali abducted Sugreevan's wife Rama).
  2. Since Vali was the Ruler of Kishkinta, if Shri Rama lodged a direct attack on Vali, he will first send his entire Army and Rama needs to destroy the army and then approach Vali. Here the entire army (Vanaras) are avathars of the Devas and have come to the earth for Rama's service.
  3. Vali knowing the nuances of Dharma willfully resorted to ill-deeds and claimed that he is only a monkey (vanara/animal). An animal can be killed from the hiding place.


P.Srinivasan

If Vali saw that there was a strong support to Sugreeva from Lord Rama he would'nt have agreed to enter into fight with Sugreeva, and Lord Rama won\'t slain a person when they are not committing anything wrong. It is comparable todays Police using a decoy to catch or kill a criminal when they actually committing the crime, like catching a drugpeddler or a militant. Lord Rama was only helping Sugreeva and he was not fighting Vali personally to have killed him face to face.


GANGA

MANY REASONS ARE THERE

  1. SINCE VALI IS VANARA AND ANIMALS ARE HUNTED AND KILLED.
  2. 2)VALI HAD THE VARA/BOON THAT ANYONE WHO IS FIGHTING HIM WILL GAIN HALF HIS POWER.


Ramkumar R

Inspite of Vali being super warrior, He followed the adharma by taking Sukriva's Wife into his Kingdom. Since the veda\'s had mentioned win dharma with dharma and adharma with adharma, Rama had follow the same rule.


Balasubramanian.V

Vali was famous for the boon that he had received, according to which anyone who came BEFORE(IN FRONT OF) him lost half his/her strength to Vali, thereby making Vali invulnerable to any enemy. Hence Rama slew him with an arrow in his back, hiding behind. Also, Rama\'s arrow cuts through seven trees before reaching Vali and killing him!.


THIRUMALAI

Because, Vali took Sugriva's wife to his enjoyment. Sri Rama says it's not a crime of His killing Vali hinding behind a tree. Even Vali feels this ok.


Ravichandran

The boon which Vali got saying he will get half of the strength of the person facing him in fight itself is unfair boon or adharma to start with. By getting this boon he loses the quality of Kshatriya. He need not be fought and killed straight. However Rama has to honour this boon and also at the same time has to counter this adharma. Moreover sita devi is better half of Rama. How can he loose half of his own strength which is nothing but Sita Devi?. Hence he was hiding and killing Vali

About why behind the tree I do not know the specific reason if any

The Sankalp of killing Vali has already been made by Rama. Once he makes the sankalp it is done . He is satya sankalpan. The mode of killing has to be dharmic to the context. yes it is indeed.


SAANTHI

VALI GOT THE BLESSING THAT NO ONE CAN KILL HIM DIRECTLY


 
 It is incorrect to believe that God has a special preference for any one language. Numerous devotees have sung and spoken to the Lord in their respective native languages and won His grace.
                                                                                                                                -- Sri Sri Muralidhara Swamiji 
 
   
 

click here to download the audio in Sri Sri Swamiji's Voice
Pronunciation | Copyright Notice | Privacy Policy